Case-Study Analysis of a “First Deal” - Posted by JD
Posted by JD on April 15, 2004 at 19:05:42:
Hi…
The following are the “numbers” for my first deal that I’m
contemplating. Specifically, I am wondering about the following
questions:
(1) Given worse-case scenario numbers, is there enough profit in it to
make this deal worthwhile to a starter investor?
(2) Are there any major flaws or deficiencies in the analysis?
(3) Are the non-remunerative lessons learned from this deal
worthwhile, even if there is a smallish profit?
Here’s the data for your consideration…
THE PROPERTY…
The home is an 850 sq.ft. 2/1 bungalow in a reviving part of Tampa on
an average-sized lot for the neighborhood. This is the second to the
ugliest home on the street within about 3 blocks, the rest of which
have already been rehabed to some extent. There is a separate 1-car
garage on property.
Home requires a variety of general repairs and updating to get an
above average neighborhood price of $130 sq.ft., including flooring,
wall resurfacing, painting, BR and kitchen updating, landscape work,
etc.
THE OWNERS…
The owners are in pre-foreclosure and not interested in pursuit ofany
theoretical equity. They are willing to allow the mortgage to be
assumed for the rehab period and are open to a Land Trust type of
transfer.
THE NUMBERS…
Appraisal value $87,500 in minimal functioning condition 2-years ago.
Current Mortgage payoff value: $67,500
Known Liens and city water meter reattachment fees: $3,000
Probable rehab cash needed: $27,500
Probable end-user resell calculated at premium sq.ft. value of $130 x
850 sq.ft = $110,000
MLS/Realtor sales commission (discounted): $5,000
Estimated months to completion: 4
Mortgage pymnts per mo.: $500
Estimated profit: $5,000
THE ASSESSMENT:
Notwithstanding the cost per-sq.ft method of appraisal, I feel like a
well-qualified couple would actually pay closer to $120,000 to
$125,000 because the place would be a “cream puff” by the time I’m
done with it. One question would be whether an appraiser would agree
to appropriate a mortgage decision on that amount.
I suppose I could do owner-financing or lease-option at a premium
and then refinance the original mortgage to re-acquire my cash and
then hope that the would-be owners take care of my property.
Any insights, random thoughts, hard lines of advice on this, my first
deal, would be tremendously appreciated.